?? Don't really understand the rejection/acception criteria for joining ??

Xiroas - perhaps in the thread with the application form, you can be a little more clear about what it is you want.

My friend, lonster, was just rejected. You say it's too short, but looking at a few others who were accepted (including my own), there's not a whole lot of substance the accepteds have that lonster did not. He did answer all the questions and gave all the info that is asked for. Some people simply aren't disposed to being very wordy just to fluff up their answers.

If you expect more, maybe you can be a little more candid about what it is you're looking for in the answers?

Well, we are an actually guild now; so we are a bit more stern on our application process; if he would look (I am not being rude) at the applications that are accepted and rejected, he should see what his app would look like. It doesn't have to be long, but if I were to C+P the words used for the application, I would expect a paragraph length.